ENS

An Unexpected Change in a Musician’s Mind

Level 3 Article Source: nytimes.com
Warm-up → or → Check Understanding → Language → Use It

A gray-haired man sits at a desk facing a monitor displaying sheet music, while a smiling woman stands beside him and gestures toward the screen.
A life in music.

After a serious motorcycle accident, music teacher Edward Freytag struggled to remember things and find words. But his brain injury also brought an unexpected change: he could hear music in a completely new way.

About two weeks after the crash, he turned on the car radio and began identifying musical notes and chords just by hearing them. He could see the written music in his mind. Although he had been a professional musician for decades, this had never happened before. He had developed “perfect pitch”—the ability to name a musical note just by hearing it.

His creativity changed, too. One morning, he discovered a piece of music more than 50 pages long on his computer. He did not remember writing it. His wife explained that he had been getting up at night to compose. The music was more unusual and complex than his usual work, with parts even he found difficult to understand.

As his brain healed, his memory and self-control improved. He became more like his old self. However, his perfect pitch and new creative ability faded.

Freytag continued composing and performing. He was proud of his later pieces, but none were quite like the unusual music he had written during recovery. Getting better had brought something valuable back—and taken something special away.

Speaker: American Male  Duration: 1:40  YouTube

Listen and Fill Gaps

Loading listening activity...

Discussion Builder
  1. Q: How do you think it feels to get better after an injury but lose a special ability at the same time?

    A:
  2. Q: What’s a sound you can recognize immediately?

    A:

Discussion Builder

  1. Q: How do you think it feels to get better after an injury but lose a special ability at the same time?

    On the other hand, / As a result,

    I'd feel glad to have my health back. On the other hand, I'd miss the special ability I'd lost.

  2. Q: What’s a sound you can recognize immediately?

    However, / For example,

    I recognize my family's voices immediately. For example, I know it's my sister as soon as she says hello.

Discussion Questions
  1. How do you think it feels to get better after an injury but lose a special ability at the same time?
  2. How would you react if you found something you’d created but couldn’t remember making it?
  3. Would you like to have perfect pitch?
  4. What’s a sound you can recognize immediately?
  5. What piece of music brings back a strong memory for you?
  6. When do you get your best creative ideas?
  7. Which matters more for becoming a good musician: natural ability or regular practice?
  8. Do you think people can have hidden abilities they don't know about?

Discussion Questions

  1. How do you think it feels to get better after an injury but lose a special ability at the same time?
  2. How would you react if you found something you’d created but couldn’t remember making it?
  3. Would you like to have perfect pitch?
  4. What’s a sound you can recognize immediately?
  5. What piece of music brings back a strong memory for you?
  6. When do you get your best creative ideas?
  7. Which matters more for becoming a good musician: natural ability or regular practice?
  8. Do you think people can have hidden abilities they don't know about?