ENS

A Military Execution in Public View

Level 4 Article Source: theguardian.com
Warm-up → or → Check Understanding → Language → Use It

A man in a dark suit gestures while speaking to another seated person, with a large television camera in the foreground.
Speaking on camera.

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says the planned execution of Nidal Hasan will be public, with a livestream allowing people to watch. He said allowing the public to watch was part of the punishment’s purpose: showing that attacks within the military carry serious consequences.

Speaking to Real America’s Voice, Hegseth said a firing squad of soldiers would carry out the sentence at Fort Hood, Texas, at 1 p.m. on Thursday, December 3. A Defense Department official later confirmed that the execution would be livestreamed. It would be the first US military execution in more than 60 years.

Hasan, a former Army psychiatrist, killed 13 people and wounded dozens more at a medical processing center at Fort Hood on November 5, 2009. A military jury sentenced him to death in 2013. After he exhausted his appeals, President Donald Trump approved the sentence on Hegseth’s recommendation.

Hegseth described the shooting as a radical Islamist attack carried out in uniform within the military. Explaining why the execution would be public, he said people needed to understand that there were “serious consequences for these types of things.” His remarks linked the choice of a military firing squad with the decision to let the public watch.

The announcement therefore concerned not only how the sentence would be carried out, but also who would see it. Hegseth’s stated aim was to make the execution a visible demonstration of the government’s response to the attack.

Speaker: American Male  Duration: 1:55  YouTube

Listen and Fill Gaps

Loading listening activity...

Discussion Builder
  1. Q: What should be the main purpose of a criminal sentence: punishment, public safety, or helping someone change?

    A:
  2. Q: Where should we draw the line between public justice and public entertainment?

    A:

Discussion Builder

  1. Q: What should be the main purpose of a criminal sentence: punishment, public safety, or helping someone change?

    given that / even though

    Public safety should come first, given that protecting people is more important than punishing criminals.

  2. Q: Where should we draw the line between public justice and public entertainment?

    nevertheless / therefore

    Justice should be open to the public; nevertheless, executions should not become entertainment.

Discussion Questions
  1. What’s your reaction to the decision to livestream an execution?
  2. What should be the main purpose of a criminal sentence: punishment, public safety, or helping someone change?
  3. Do you think public executions discourage crime?
  4. Where should we draw the line between public justice and public entertainment?
  5. How might soldiers feel about being ordered to carry out an execution?
  6. Should soldiers be punished differently from civilians for serious crimes?
  7. Is life in prison a better punishment than execution?

Discussion Questions

  1. What’s your reaction to the decision to livestream an execution?
  2. What should be the main purpose of a criminal sentence: punishment, public safety, or helping someone change?
  3. Do you think public executions discourage crime?
  4. Where should we draw the line between public justice and public entertainment?
  5. How might soldiers feel about being ordered to carry out an execution?
  6. Should soldiers be punished differently from civilians for serious crimes?
  7. Is life in prison a better punishment than execution?