ENS

20-Year-Old Lottery Winner Chooses Weekly Payments

Level 4 Article Source: finance.yahoo.com
Warm-up → or → Check Understanding → Language → Use It

Close-up photo of a $1,000,000 scratch-off lottery ticket on a wooden table, with three piggy bank icons revealed in a scratched silver panel and scratch-off flakes scattered around.
A winning scratch ticket.

Many lottery winners must choose between a large one-time payment and smaller payments. A 20-year-old woman from Quebec, Canada, Brenda Aubin-Vega, faced that choice after winning the top prize on a scratch ticket. She saw three piggy bank symbols and froze. "I couldn't believe my eyes! I checked my ticket over and over again," she told Yahoo News Canada. She called her dad, took time off work, and then picked a weekly payment of $1,000 instead of a $1 million cash prize.

Her decision drew criticism online and started a debate about money today versus money later. In the United States, lottery income is taxed by federal, state, and local governments, so big jackpots shrink fast. A $1.5 billion Powerball winner would keep about $516.7 million after federal taxes. Aubin-Vega is Canadian, and lottery prizes there are not taxed, so she could have taken the $1 million with no penalty.

The weekly plan gives her $52,000 a year, which works like a 5.2% yearly return on $1 million. The money comes from the province of Quebec and is backed by its government, so the risk is very low. Her age also matters: at $1,000 a week she reaches $1 million at 39 and about $3.1 million by 80.

A fixed weekly payment offers little flexibility, while a $1 million cash payment could be invested in many kinds of assets. A low-cost fund that follows the stock market and grows 7% a year could turn $1 million into several million in about 10 years. Inflation also reduces buying power over time. With 2% yearly price rises, $1,000 a week could be worth less than half its current value by age 56. The weekly choice also removes the chance to brag about being a 20-year-old millionaire.

Speaker: American Female  Duration: 2:17  YouTube

Listen and Fill Gaps

Loading listening activity...

Discussion Builder
  1. Q: What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?

    A:
  2. Q: What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?

    A:

Discussion Builder

  1. Because of that, / For example, / Also, / Still,

    Her decision drew criticism online and started a debate about money today versus money later. Because of that, it became a trending topic across social media.

  2. Q: What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?

    So, / For example, / Still, / Also,

    Lottery prizes in Canada are not taxed. So, she could have taken the $1 million with no penalty.

  3. Q: What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?

    However, / As a result, / For example, / Furthermore,

    A fixed weekly payment offers little flexibility. However, a $1 million cash payment could be invested in many kinds of assets.

  4. Therefore, / However, / For example, / In addition,

    Inflation reduces buying power over time. Therefore, the weekly payment feels like much less money in the future.

Discussion Questions
  1. Did Brenda make the right choice, in your opinion?
  2. What are the benefits of receiving money every week?
  3. What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?
  4. Would you prefer a large one-time payment or smaller weekly payments? Why?
  5. Is inflation a problem in your country? How have prices changed in recent years?
  6. Is a low-cost fund that follows the stock market a good investment? Why do you think so?
  7. What are some other investments that you would consider?
  8. When it comes to investing, do you prefer low-risk, low-reward, or high-risk, high-reward?
  9. Is it smart to take time off work after a big win? Why or why not?
  10. If you received $1,000 a week, how would you use it?

Discussion Questions

  1. Did Brenda make the right choice, in your opinion?
  2. What are the benefits of receiving money every week?
  3. What are the advantages of a large one-time payment?
  4. Would you prefer a large one-time payment or smaller weekly payments? Why?
  5. Is inflation a problem in your country? How have prices changed in recent years?
  6. Is a low-cost fund that follows the stock market a good investment? Why do you think so?
  7. What are some other investments that you would consider?
  8. When it comes to investing, do you prefer low-risk, low-reward, or high-risk, high-reward?
  9. Is it smart to take time off work after a big win? Why or why not?
  10. If you received $1,000 a week, how would you use it?